British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond (2nd R), U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry (R) and European Union High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Federica Mogherini  (L) talk to Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif as the wait for Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov (not pictured) for a group picture at the Vienna International Center in Vienna, Austria July 14, 2015. REUTERS/Carlos Barria

Cleric Challenges Nuclear Deal with World Powers

By Bozorgmehr Sharafedin Nouri and Babak Dehghanpisheh

DUBAI/BEIRUT (Reuters) – A senior cleric challenged Iran’s historic nuclear deal with world powers on Friday, echoing a cautious early assessment of the accord by Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, an arch-conservative who has the last word on matters of state.

Ayatollah Mohammad Ali Movahedi Kermani did not dismiss the accord in his remarks at Friday prayers in Tehran, but his language was sufficiently tough — some terms of the deal were an “insult” and “excessive”, he said — to indicate significant unease about the accord within Iran’s clerical establishment.

His remarks will be seen by Iranians as reflecting Khamenei’s views and contrast with the praise given to the accord by President Hassan Rouhani and Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif, who plan to use the deal as the basis for a charm offensive among Iran’s wary Arab neighbors.

Kermani said Iran would accept a deal only if sanctions were lifted immediately, frozen revenues were returned and Tehran’s revolutionary ideals, including its fight with “global arrogance” – a term for the West and Israel — were preserved.

“They have some excessive demands,” he said, objecting to restrictions placed on the number of centrifuges Iran can operate, on its nuclear research and development and on its handling of enriched uranium.

Political analysts said the comments by Khamenei and Kermani allow conservative clerics the political space to make further criticisms of the deal and could also absolve the Supreme Leader of responsibility if the accord, which will last for years, falls apart at some future stage.

At the same time their criticism is not so severe as to torpedo the deal and block a lifting of sanctions – something ordinary Iranians are desperate to see happen to restore a normal economy.


“They say … Iran’s nuclear program should be limited and Iran should accept a comprehensive nuclear inspection regime … These are excessive demands.”

Under the deal agreed on Tuesday, sanctions will be gradually removed in return for Iran accepting long-term curbs on a nuclear program that the West has suspected was aimed at creating a nuclear bomb.

Iran, which says its nuclear work is for civilian purposes, sees its program as a symbol of national pride and resilience in the face of what it sees as decades of hostility from Western countries that opposed its 1979 Islamic revolution.

Kermani’s criticism underlined concerns expressed in the past two days by some conservative figures within Iran’s political establishment and media, and repeated the term Khamenei used to describe some of Tehran’s negotiating partners – “untrustworthy”.

Kermani said Iran’s nuclear scientists and scholars should now scrutinize the deal and discuss it.

“This is important as I have heard some critics saying the deal has not preserved the Supreme Leader’s red lines,” he said.

Zarif will brief parliament on the deal on July 21, according to some Iranian media, and it will also be examined by the country’s top security body, its National Security Council.

Khamenei was quoted on Wednesday as saying that reaching a deal was “a significant step” but the text should be carefully scrutinized along with the legal procedures.


Kermani also handed some praise to Iran’s negotiators for their work in the marathon talks in Vienna, saying Tehran’s negotiating partners had been forced “to retreat”.

“Israel and its allies, especially Saudi Arabia, are extremely unhappy about this deal, and this is the best proof to show how valuable the deal is. As Iran’s martyred cleric, Beheshti, used to say: ‘Let them be angry and die from their anger.'”

Beheshti was seen as the number two in Iran’s political framework after the revolution. He was assassinated in a bomb blast at a political party conference in 1981.

Zarif, embarking on a diplomatic offensive in the wake of the deal, told fellow Muslim countries that Iran hoped the nuclear accord could pave the way for more cooperation in the Middle East and internationally.

In a message to Islamic and Arab countries on the occasion of the Eid al-Fitr holiday at the end of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, he said: “By solving the artificial crisis about its nuclear program diplomatically, a new opportunity for regional and international cooperation has emerged.”

Zarif would travel to Gulf countries at some point after the Eid holiday, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Marzieh Afkham told state news agency IRNA late on Thursday.

She said Iran was seriously determined to further expand ties with regional states and its neighbors, some of which include Sunni Muslim Gulf Arab states who accuse Shi’ite power Tehran of interfering in the Arab world.

(Writing by William Maclean, Editing by Peter Millership)

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *